Two towns on opposite sides of the United States are reshaping how they oversee short-term rentals, the homes and rooms booked by visitors for stays of less than 30 days. In Columbia Falls, Montana, a proposed fee increase of more than 500% dominated a recent city council meeting. In Clayton, New York, village officials gathered public comment on a package of proposed regulations that would cover parking, occupancy, noise and lighting.
Columbia Falls weighs a sharp rise in permit fees
The Columbia Falls policy would create a single permit process for every short-term rental operator, regardless of zoning. Anyone renting out any part of a dwelling to transient guests would fall under the rules. City staff introduced the draft earlier this month, and the council is still refining it. Under the current proposal, a new operator would pay $400 for an initial permit, up from $325. Operators who already hold a permit and follow city rules would pay an annual renewal fee of $250, compared with the current $40.
Most of the residents who spoke at Monday’s meeting were short-term rental owners themselves. Several said the increase would squeeze small operators, often described as “mom and pop” owners who rely on rental income. Todd Schleusner told the council that higher fees would push him to raise rents or leave the business altogether. He added that many owners are local families trying to make ends meet, not large corporations. Residents also pointed to the 3% resort tax and other charges, arguing that the combined costs make it harder to compete with nearby rentals in the county, where permit enforcement is looser.
City Manager Eric Hanks defended the fees as cost recovery. He said the purpose is to cover program administration and enforcement, not to raise money for unrelated government spending. The city estimates the program will cost just over $68,000 a year, including about $8,500 for third-party monitoring and permitting software and nearly $60,000 for staff time. The new fees are expected to bring in an estimated $40,750, which leaves a shortfall of roughly $27,000. Hanks said residents want strong services but also low fees, and the council has to find a balance between the two.
Unpaid resort tax drives the push for stricter enforcement
The city believes a tougher program will recover money it is currently missing. Officials estimate between $150,000 and $250,000 in unpaid short-term rental resort tax over the past four years. Hanks said many non-paying operators had already spoken with city staff at some point but did not provide complete information, or started and then stopped paying the tax. He said the city will go after those balances, which it views as money that could support public safety and infrastructure projects.
The council has asked staff to examine whether operators who remain consistently compliant could receive a lower renewal fee. Councilor John Piper said he would like to see a way to reward continued compliance, though he acknowledged that the cost of running a stricter program may be hard to avoid. Several councilors shared the view that the expense is what it takes to run an effective system.
Clayton proposes permits, limits and noise standards
In Clayton, the village is considering rules for short-term rentals like those listed on Airbnb and Vrbo. The draft covers parking, occupancy limits, noise and lighting standards. It would also require owners to obtain a village permit, which would let officials track how many short-term rentals operate in the community. Mayor Nancy Hyde said the goal is to protect residents while still welcoming visitors, because the village wants to keep tourism and a strong sense of community.
Reaction at the informational meeting was mixed. Alison Mullarney, who runs an Airbnb, said she supports some parts of the proposal but questioned others. She pointed out that owners already pay county tax and a bed tax, so a permit would add another cost. She said she has seen few problems with existing noise and lighting ordinances and does not know how much more regulation is needed. Mike Ascough, the village zoning officer, took a different view. He said the most frequent complaints he receives involve noise and lighting from neighbors, often late at night, and he believes rules are needed to curb disruptive behavior.
Clayton will hold another informational meeting on December 9. Officials do not expect any measure to be approved until early next year.



