Skip to content
19 November 2026

Vacation rental rules in Hawaii and El Dorado County

Hawaii County has adopted a long-debated rental bill, and El Dorado County is preparing its own overhaul of vacation rental permits, occupancy caps and inspections.

Vacation rental rules in Hawaii and El Dorado County

Two California and Hawaii counties are reshaping how short-term rentals operate, each responding to a mix of owner complaints and resident worries about noise, traffic and neighborhood character. In Hawaii, the rules took months of hearings and amendments before reaching a final form. In El Dorado County, a set of proposed changes is moving through the Board of Supervisors ahead of a final decision.

Hawaii County passes Bill 147 after months of amendments

The Hawaiʻi County Council approved the fourth draft of Bill 147, which sets out operational standards and defines what counts as a short-term rental. The bill splits these rentals into hosted rentals, where the owner lives on site, and unhosted rentals, where they do not. It also names the zoning districts where each type can operate, and it raises the threshold for a short-term stay to any rental under 180 days, up from 30 days. Violations will carry fines that feed an enforcement fund.

Much of the public testimony opposed the bill, but Council Member Heather Kimball argued that it simplifies the process. She said it spares qualifying rentals from applying for use permits under registration rules that took effect on Sept. 1, which were set by Ordinance 20-25 and built on legislation passed in June 2025. Owners of hosted rentals pay a $250 initial fee and a $100 yearly renewal. Unhosted operators pay $500 up front and $250 each year. Jeff Darrow, director of the Planning Department, said the department had been holding off on enforcement because the zoning code offered no clear guidance, and staff were relying on the bill to set that direction.

Testifiers at the Nov. 6 meeting asked for warnings before any fines were imposed, and the fourth draft responds to that request. The Planning Director must first send a warning letter that identifies the violated chapter, the factual basis for the violation and the possible penalties. Owners then have time to stop the violation, correct it, or submit a written response showing that no violation occurred. Fines start at $5,500 for a first violation, rise to $7,500 for a second, and reach $10,000 for each later violation. The director must verify the violation before assessing a fine, and may charge a fine for each day the violation continues.

Clark Kahawaiʻi, who manages vacation rentals professionally, said he had opposed the bill at first but now sees many industry members as satisfied with the revisions. He welcomed the added warnings, though he urged the council and the Planning Department to educate residents about the rules. He noted that if professional rental managers find some details unclear, the public will likely find them harder still.

El Dorado County weighs looser limits and stricter enforcement

The El Dorado County Board of Supervisors is considering changes to its vacation rental ordinance for areas west of the Lake Tahoe Basin. The proposal would relax the 500-foot rule that blocks new permits near existing rentals, but only for west slope parcels of 5 acres or more. It would also raise occupancy limits, allowing two people per bedroom plus two additional guests, and it would stop counting children aged 12 and younger toward that total. Hosted rentals outside the basin would allow two guests per bedroom, not counting the owner’s bedroom, and guest houses would be permitted countywide. In August, the county had 746 permitted rentals in the Tahoe Basin and 192 on the west slope.

On the enforcement side, the county would carry out proactive investigations rather than rely only on complaints, and it could inspect permitted rentals during business hours with 48 hours of written notice. A rental that receives four violations within 18 months would lose its permit for one year. A county survey with 363 responses found that about two-thirds of respondents supported the changes. Opponents, including Scott and Deb Matyac and Placerville resident Janet Barbieri, warned that larger groups would bring more noise, traffic and parking problems to rural neighborhoods.

Owners say the current limits cut into their income. Kris Linquist, a Pollock Pines rental owner, reported that bookings fell by about 40 percent after the occupancy restrictions took effect in 2024. The El Dorado County Farm Bureau, through its president Michael Ranalli, backed reasonable standards but asked the county to focus on demonstrable impacts and to clarify the scope of proactive enforcement. The group also asked for a limit on the 48-hour inspection requirement and an appeals process for restrictions on local contacts and marketing.

The board gave preliminary approval to the changes by a 4-1 vote, with Supervisor Lori Parlin dissenting. The ordinance returns for final approval on Dec. 8.

Thomas Hughes
Author

Thomas Hughes

Thomas Hughes, a property and real estate journalist, reports on the housing market, second-home purchases and mortgage trends, guiding buyers and sellers through property decisions.