New York City has issued more than $500 million in bills under the pied-à-terre tax, a surcharge on luxury second homes championed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani. The total arrived even though the number of homeowners who received bills came in well below the early projections.
Mamdani announced the milestone on X on Tuesday. He described the sum as half a billion dollars to put toward a city that works for all New Yorkers. The surcharge is central to his plan to raise taxes on wealthy residents and narrow the city’s budget gap.
Bills, exemptions and a shrinking list of properties
The New York City Department of Finance mailed about 7,500 tax bills. That figure is a steep decline from the roughly 17,000 notices sent to property owners over the summer. Officials also granted around 8,900 exemption applications and rejected about 1,600 extension requests. Owners whose properties qualify for an exemption do not pay the surcharge.
The tax follows a sliding scale tied to property value, so the most expensive homes carry the highest charges. It covers certain one- to three-family homes valued at $5 million or more, along with condos and co-ops valued at $1 million or more. Officials said the combined billed amount passed the $500 million goal that Governor Kathy Hochul had set earlier this year. They have not yet released a breakdown explaining how that total was reached across the roughly 7,500 properties.
A spokesperson for the Department of Finance, Julia Agos, said owners of second homes worth more than $5 million should accept a responsibility to the city that makes those properties valuable. The department says it will keep applying the surcharge fairly and efficiently so that those best able to pay contribute.
Earlier projections and the court fight
The city comptroller’s office first put the numbers in perspective in an April report. It estimated that a version of the tax could raise about $500 million from more than 11,200 properties, before exemptions and changes in owner behavior were counted. Once those factors were included, the report projected revenue of roughly $340 million to $380 million. Mamdani has nonetheless said he remains confident the surcharge can bring in half a billion dollars a year.
The state Legislature approved the surcharge in May. Earlier this month, a state appeals court unanimously dismissed a lawsuit that challenged how the city rolled out the tax. The court ruled that the homeowners who filed the suit lacked legal standing, which reversed a lower court order requiring the city to restart implementation.
The tax still faces other legal challenges, including claims that it is unconstitutional. Homeowners may also contest their bills before the city’s Tax Commission, which could lower the total over time. Mamdani’s office and the Department of Finance have been asked to comment on the latest figures.



