The city’s Department of Finance announced this week that more than $500 million in bills have been sent to owners of high-value secondary residences. Pied-à-terre tax bills were mailed to about 7,500 properties, a sharp drop from the 17,000 notices issued last summer that warned owners they could be subject to the surcharge.
Eligibility hinges on a property’s assessed value: one- to three-family homes must be worth at least $5 million, while co-ops and condos qualify at $1 million or more, provided the unit is not the owner’s primary residence. Those who can prove they live in the home for most of the year receive an exemption, while others face a charge that rises with the property’s market price.
Billing the tax: numbers and exemptions
Initial outreach in July listed roughly 17,000 potential targets. After a wave of exemption applications, the city approved about 8,900 requests, leaving an estimated 7,500 owners with a bill to pay. Roughly 1,600 extension requests were denied, meaning those households must settle the amount before the next deadline.
The surcharge operates on a sliding-scale basis. For example, a Gilded Age mansion on East 72nd Street could owe $1.456 million, while a penthouse at 220 Central Park South, purchased by hedge-fund billionaire Ken Griffin for $238 million, might be assessed at just over $1 million. These figures illustrate how the tax disproportionately affects the most valuable assets.
How the calculation works
Each qualifying property is assigned a rate that corresponds to its valuation tier. The higher the assessed price, the larger the percentage applied, resulting in bills that can exceed six figures for the most expensive homes. The department has not released a detailed breakdown of the 7,500 properties by bracket, but officials maintain that the total collection will meet or exceed the $500 million target.
Political and legal backdrop
Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul championed the levy as part of a broader “tax the rich” agenda aimed at narrowing the city’s budget deficit. The legislation was passed by the state legislature in May and has since become a focal point of partisan debate.
Earlier this month, a Brooklyn appeals court ruled unanimously that the city could continue implementing the surcharge, dismissing a lawsuit that claimed the rollout was “arbitrary and capricious.” The court found the plaintiffs lacked standing, allowing the city to proceed while other challenges, particularly those questioning the tax’s constitutionality, remain unresolved.
Mayor’s stance
Mayor Mamdani reiterated his confidence, stating that the revenue will fund services that benefit all New Yorkers. He emphasized that ownership of a multi-million-dollar Second home carries a civic responsibility, echoing remarks from Department of Finance spokesperson Julia Agos.
Revenue outlook and criticism
The administration asserts the surcharge will generate “half a billion dollars per year,” yet the path to that figure is contested. City Comptroller Mark Levine’s April analysis, based on an estimated 11,200 eligible units, projected a range of $340 million to $380 million after accounting for exemptions and likely changes in owner behavior.
When the Comptroller’s office updated its projection in June, it suggested the tax could bring in at least $1 billion before exemptions, implying the $500 million goal remains attainable. However, real-estate market analyst Jonathan Miller warned that the model may not reflect how owners will adjust their usage patterns to avoid the levy.
Legal counsel’s view
Attorney Ben Williams, who reviews property-tax matters for Rosenberg & Estis, examined the city’s published property-value list and estimated that, without exemptions, the tax base could exceed $1.7 billion. He calculated that roughly 2,600 of the highest-valued homes would be needed to reach the $500 million mark, assuming none secured an exemption.
Williams cautioned that many owners are likely to contest the assessment “tooth and nail,” noting that some of his clients have already prepared legal challenges. The combination of aggressive litigation and potential changes in residency declarations could erode the projected revenue.
While the city has successfully billed over $500 million against luxury second homes, the final fiscal impact will depend on the outcome of ongoing lawsuits, the effectiveness of exemption reviews, and how owners respond to the new financial obligation.



