Skip to content
28 August 2026

Short-term vs mid-term rentals: Which model is best for your second home

Make an informed decision about your second home investment with our comprehensive guide to short-term and mid-term rentals

Short-term vs mid-term rentals: Which model is best for your second home

When it comes to investing in a second home, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is how to rent it out. Two popular options are short-term rentals (STR) and mid-term rentals (MTR). In this article, we’ll explore the economics, regulations, and operations of both models, including occupancy, pricing, and turnover models.

Short-term rentals typically involve renting out a property for a short period, usually less than 30 days. This model is often used for vacation homes or properties in tourist areas. Occupancy rates for STRs can be high, especially during peak season, but pricing can be volatile, with rates fluctuating depending on demand.

Mid-term rentals

Mid-term rentals involve renting out a property for a longer period, usually between 30 days and 6 months. This model is often used for properties in urban areas or for tenants who need a temporary place to stay. Turnover models for MTRs can be more predictable, with longer-term tenants and less frequent vacancies.

Economics of STR and MTR

The economics of STR and MTR differ significantly. STRs typically generate higher revenue per night, but may have higher operating costs due to frequent turnovers and marketing expenses. MTRs, on the other hand, may generate lower revenue per month, but often have lower operating costs and more predictable income streams.

Regulations and operations

Regulations and operations for STR and MTR also vary. STRs are often subject to local regulations and licensing requirements while MTRs may be subject to tenant protection laws and lease agreements. Property management companies can help owners navigate these regulations and manage the day-to-day operations of their rental properties.

Decision trees

To decide between STR and MTR, owners should consider their investment goalstarget market and local regulations. A decision tree can help owners evaluate these factors and choose the best model for their second home. For example, if an owner wants to maximize revenue and is willing to take on more risk, an STR model may be the best choice. However, if an owner prioritizes predictability and stability, an MTR model may be more suitable.

By understanding these factors and using a decision tree, owners can make an informed decision about which model is best for their second home investment.

Thomas Hughes
Author

Thomas Hughes

Thomas Hughes, a property and real estate journalist, reports on the housing market, second-home purchases and mortgage trends, guiding buyers and sellers through property decisions.