Skip to content
24 August 2026

Discover the Historic Old St. Augustine Hills Estate for Sale

A stunning 100-acre Florida estate with a private baseball field and a luxurious custom home is now available for $9.6 million after 23 years under the same ownership.

Discover the Historic Old St. Augustine Hills Estate for Sale

The picturesque landscape of Old St. Augustine Hills, just outside Tallahassee, is home to a remarkable estate that has recently entered the real estate market. This 100-acre property, known for its rich history and luxurious amenities, is now available for $9.6 million offering a unique blend of historic charm and modern elegance.

The estate’s allure begins with its 6,000-square-foot custom cypress post-and-beam residence meticulously designed by owner and interior designer René Hanselman in collaboration with architect Ken Pieper. Built in 2005, the home exemplifies exceptional craftsmanship and timeless design, making it a standout feature of this extraordinary property.

The Architectural Splendor of Old St. Augustine Hills

The main dwelling is a testament to thoughtful design and natural materials, offering endless inspiration for those passionate about home design. The residence features extensive custom casework and a seamless integration with its surrounding landscape, creating a harmonious living environment.

Inside, the home boasts six bedrooms and 7.5 bathrooms, providing ample space for both family living and grand entertaining. The interior design reflects a perfect balance of rustic warmth and modern sophistication, ensuring a comfortable and luxurious lifestyle.

As a turnkey offering, the estate includes custom furniture, fine artwork, and modern Lutron and Sonos systems, allowing new owners to immediately enjoy a lifestyle of effortless luxury. The property’s meticulous maintenance ensures a frictionless transition for its next inhabitants.

A Legacy of Athletic Excellence

Beyond the main house, the estate’s 100-acre grounds are renowned for their deep connections to college and professional baseball legends. Past visitors and previous owners include iconic sports figures like former New York Yankees manager Dick Howser and FSU coach Mike Martin, adding a layer of athletic heritage to the property’s rich history.

The crown jewel of the outdoor amenities is a fully irrigated private baseball field, complete with professional chalk lines, an official scoreboard, and a lighted batting cage. This unique recreational feature offers a fascinating glimpse into specialized architecture and custom property amenities tailored to specific passions.

Property buyers seeking versatility will appreciate that the ballfield can easily be adapted into a pickleball court, tennis courts, or equestrian paddocks. The diverse grounds also feature spring-fed bass ponds, a serene cypress duck pond, a cascading waterfall pool, and a fully equipped wood-fired outdoor kitchen, perfect for ultimate weekend gatherings.

The Historical Significance of Old St. Augustine Road

The estate’s location along Old St. Augustine Road adds to its historical significance. Dating back to the 1680s, this road was part of the Spanish El Camino Real, and the property sits along the Cody Scarp, an ancient shoreline that contributes to its rolling terrain and natural springs.

After 23 years under the ownership of David and René Hanselman, the estate is now ready for new stewards to continue its legacy. As the Hanselmans’ children have grown and moved on, the time has come for a new family to experience the unique charm and luxury of Old St. Augustine Hills.

The estate is listed with Jon Kohler & Associates, offering a rare opportunity to own a piece of Florida’s rich history and athletic heritage.

Thomas Hughes
Author

Thomas Hughes

Thomas Hughes, a property and real estate journalist, reports on the housing market, second-home purchases and mortgage trends, guiding buyers and sellers through property decisions.